Who Is Igniting Antisemitism in America?
The ADL Data Tells A Story Very Different From The Media Narrative
ADDENDUM: In light of additional information regarding the below cited ADL data, the below data should only be understood with critical additional context not fully available at the time of this article’s publication. Therefore, I request before reading below, please see my updated article on this ADL Data. Thank you.
Antisemitism is bad. It is wrong. It is dehumanizing. Period.
There’s no “but” after the above statements, and there’s no debate about the evilness of antisemitism.
The purpose of this post is to understand the source of antisemitism in America, because the facts tell us a very different story than the media narrative. While several media reports in the previous few months sought to malign peaceful university students protesting the siege on Gaza as antisemitic, the truth historically and contemporarily demonstrates otherwise. Let’s pull out the receipts.
I looked up the Anti-Defamation League (“ADL”) data on antisemitic hate crimes in America. The ADL H.E.A.T. Map data goes back to 2002. If you had to guess what percentage of antisemitic hate crimes were from Muslims vs Leftists vs Right over the past 22 years, what would you guess? Hold that thought.
Let's start with antisemitic hate crimes by Muslims or "Islamists" as the ADL calls them. Would you believe that since 2002, the ADL records exactly 0 antisemitic hate crimes by Muslims? ZERO.
So what about leftists? Well, you might be surprised once more.
According to the ADL, since 2002, leftists have been responsible for a whopping...0 antisemitic hate crimes. ZERO.
So to keep count. Zero antisemitic hate crimes from Muslims. Zero antisemitic hate crimes from leftists. What percent then, shall we guess, does the Right account for in antisemitic hate crimes since 2002?
According to the ADL, since 2002, the Right has been responsible for an incredible, a horrifying, a sickening 100% of antisemitic hate crimes—totaling at least 3058 antisemitic hate crimes. And it's getting worse.
So to quickly recap—per ADL, perpetrators of antisemitic hate crimes in the United States of America since 2002 are:
0% Muslim
0% Leftist
100% Right Wing
Would you have known that following the media narrative demonizing Muslims and the politically left leaning college students and organizations?
As we watch an interfaith cohort of university students—Jewish, Muslim, Christian, Sikh, people of no faith and every faith—stand united for justice for Palestine, it is critical we ensure antisemitic provocateurs do not detract from their efforts for justice. It is critical we stand united—Muslims, Jews, Christians, Sikhs, people of all faith & no faith—against all antisemitism, Islamophobia, & xenophobia. Indeed, it is powerful to watch Jewish students at Columbia lead the charge and condemn the weaponization of antisemitism against their efforts to promote peace and justice.
If we do not stand united against hate, we risk allowing right wing extremists to drive both the media narrative, and also the policy narrative. That will harm Jews, Muslims, and every minority group in America. We must uphold justice above all else. That is the path to peace.
Thank you for this data. I am not surprised that the data shows what it shows. Once again, I have to ask the so called right, why are you lying? Just own it because it is who you are.
Allan Kulikoff, retired academic, and an anti-Zionist, supposedly self-hating Jew since 1968, when I told a colleague at the GWU Hillel that Israel needed the conquered territories like they needed a hole in the head (I used a Yiddish expression). Your data analysis is right on because you have properly excluded ADL's "data" that calls many anti-genocide protests (with Jewish participants) antisemitic.