UN Commission: The IDF Is Raping, Killing, & Torturing Palestinians
Legacy media has conducted a near blackout of this damning report and the Biden administration is refusing to act to uphold international human rights law
Rape, torture, beatings, bombings, starvation, kidnappings, and indefinite detention of Palestinians summarize the third report by the Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel. The UN backed Commission submitted its third report to the General Assembly weeks ago, and yet legacy media has continued to pretend it does not exist.
The UN Commission also documents and condemns war crimes committed by Hamas—including taking of Israeli hostages. It does not make excuses for, or defend those war crimes. In doing so, the UN Commission demonstrates its objectivity, reemphasizing the fact that war crimes do not justify more war crimes.
I launched Let’s Address This with Qasim Rashid to particularly cover the human rights issues legacy media continues to ignore. Below is a concise overview of this devastating UN report, and a reminder of why we must not relent in our demands for justice and enforcement of International Human Rights Law. Let’s Address This.
While I encourage everyone to read the full report linked above, I want to focus on three key findings from this report, that of course, legacy media is underreporting.
The Israeli military attacks on healthcare facilities and the impact that has on reproductive healthcare for women and pediatric care for children.
The allegation from the Israeli military that Hamas is using hospitals as military bases.
The treatment of Palestinians in Israeli prisons.
1. Israeli military attacks on healthcare
The UN Commission cites the World Health Organization to detail Israel’s extensive attacks on healthcare facilities—which are war crimes. The data is daunting. Between 7 October 2023 and 30 July 2024, the Israeli military:
Carried out 498 attacks on healthcare facilities in the Gaza Strip.
747 persons were killed directly in those attacks, 969 others were injured, and 110 facilities were affected.
78% of the attacks between 7 October 2023 and 12 February 2024 were carried out through military force, 35% involved obstruction of access, and 9% involved militarized search and detention operations.
The impact on women and reproductive healthcare has been nothing short of utterly devastating. The UN Commission reports:
Direct attacks on health-care facilities, including those offering sexual and reproductive health care and services, have affected about 540,000 women and girls who are of reproductive age in Gaza.
The Basmah in vitro fertilization centre, the largest fertility clinic in Gaza, was the direct target of air strikes in December 2023 that reportedly resulted in the destruction of approximately 3,000 embryos.
Women have increasingly been forced to give birth in unsafe conditions at home or in shelters or camps, with little or no medical support, increasing the risk of complications resulting in life-long injuries and death.
Obstetric emergencies and premature births have reportedly surged because of stress and trauma. An increase in miscarriages of up to 300% has been reported. Experts told the Commission that the long-term psychological and physical effects of such precarious conditions for women, newborns and the family remain unknown.
Similarly, the Israeli military attacks on hospitals has left the most vulnerable among us—our children—to suffer unimaginable horrors. Yet, these horrors unfold right before our eyes. The UN Commission reports about the impact of Israel’s siege on children:
Medical professionals told the Commission that they have treated children with direct gunshot wounds, indicating direct targeting of children.
In June, the United Nations Children’s Fund estimated that almost 3,000 malnourished children were at risk of dying owing to the lack of food in southern Gaza.
Hospitals in Gaza can no longer offer mental health treatment and have few specialized staff to treat children suffering psychological conditions, including those exhibiting suicidal and self-harming thoughts.
Doctors told the Commission that, as a result of attacks on medical facilities and the limited treatment options available, infants and children in Gaza would likely suffer well into their adulthood.
Now, the Israeli government claims all of this suffering is justified, and their attacks on hospitals are justified. Why? Because, as Netanyahu continues to claim, Hamas is using these hospitals for military purposes, including as “command-and-control” centers. The independent UN Commission directly rebukes this claim.
Allegation that Hamas uses hospitals as a military base
Did Hamas use hospitals in Gaza as their secret military bases? The UN report tackled this important question in detail. International Human Rights Law makes it explicitly clear that hospitals and medical institutions are protected from attack. The exception that IHL recognizes is when a hospital or medical facility is used:
Outside their humanitarian functions [and] "act harmful to the enemy". In case of doubt as to whether medical units of establishments are used to commit an "act harmful to the enemy", they should be presumed not to be so used.
And though IHL does not explicitly define the scope of “an act harmful to the enemy,” IHL clarifies that when in doubt—hospitals and medical institutions must remain protected. This means that in bombing 110 healthcare facilities, the Israeli military should have had explicitly clear knowledge that Hamas was using these facilities as “command-and-control” centers in violation of IHL. And if the Israeli government had explicitly clear knowledge, then they should have zero trouble providing ample evidence, example after example, that Hamas is using hospitals in violation of IHL.
On the contrary, the detailed UN Commission concluded the following:
Israeli security forces asserted that over 85% of major medical facilities in Gaza were used by Hamas for terror operations, but did not provide evidence to substantiate that claim. Israeli security forces alleged that there were tunnels underneath or connected to hospitals, and that Hamas stored weapons, hid personnel and operated headquarters from within and underneath hospitals. The Commission interviewed senior medical personnel at hospitals and they denied that there was any military activity, emphasizing that the hospitals’ only role was to treat patients.
Let’s unpack this. The Israeli military first claims that only 85% of the 110 medical facilities it targeted were used for “Hamas terror operations.” That means that it admits 15% of the medical facilities it targeted had no Hamas terror operations, but the Israeli military targeted them anyway. That in and of itself is a clear admission of war crimes. And that is all that should be necessary for the US Government, indeed the global West, to stop arming Netanyahu.
But adding to these war crimes is that even in the “85% (allegedly) legitimate targets,” the Israeli government could provide no evidence to substantiate its claims. The UN Commission found zero evidence from the Israeli government, or from a single senior medical personnel at the hospitals that any military activity occurred at the hospitals that the Israeli military bombed. Yet, the bombings continue, in complete violation of IHL. And given that these bombings are deliberate and intentional, I argue this satisfies the “intent” element of proving genocide. Indeed, beyond war crimes, the Israeli military bombing 110 hospitals and medical centers in Gaza, while knowing full well they are not Hamas military command centers, proves they are intentionally killing Palestinian civilians. That is genocide.
Treatment of Palestinians in Israeli prisons
Finally, the UN Commission reports a ghastly scene on how the Israeli military is treating the tens of thousands of Palestinians it has arbitrarily arrested. Of the 14,000 Palestinians arbitrarily arrested from Gaza and the West Bank since October 7 of last year, at least 11,000 remain in Israeli custody—most without charge, due process, or access to counsel. They are hostages by any other name. And their mistreatment amounts to more war crimes. The UN Commission found that even after the Israeli military admits a detained Palestinian is of no threat, he or she remains arbitrarily detained without cause. The report additionally concludes these horrifying facts:
As at 15 July, at least 53 Palestinian detainees had died in Israeli detention facilities since 7 October 2023. Of that number, 44 persons were from Gaza, including 36 who died in Sde Teiman, and 9 were from the West Bank. Deceased detainees’ bodies have largely not been returned to their families for burial.
Israel provided no evidence that investigations into deaths in custody were being conducted, with a view to ensuring accountability.
Hundreds of children from Gaza and the West Bank were arrested and then transferred and detained in Israel and the West Bank. Detained children were subjected to extreme violence during arrest, detention, interrogation and release.
Detainees, including older individuals, taken to Sde Teiman for interrogation were tied in painful positions or bound to a screw placed high on a wall for hours, while blindfolded and suspended with their feet touching or barely touching the ground (“shabah”). The Commission also received reports of electric shock devices being used against detainees.
The Commission documented more than 20 cases of sexual and gender-based violence against male and female detainees in more than 10 military and Israel Prison Service facilities, in particular in Negev prison and Sde Teiman camp for male detainees and in Damon and Hasharon prisons for female detainees.
The Commission found that forced nudity, with the aim of degrading and humiliating victims in front of both soldiers and other detainees, was frequently used against male victims. Several male detainees reported that Israeli security forces personnel had beaten, kicked, pulled or squeezed their genitals.
One detainee who had been held in the Israeli security forces personnel Negev prison stated that, in November 2023, he was forced to strip and then ordered to kiss the Israeli flag. When he refused, he was beaten and his genitals were kicked so severely that he vomited and lost consciousness.
The Israeli authorities have not disclosed the names and whereabouts of the thousands of Palestinians from Gaza arrested since 7 October, including in response to several habeas corpus petitions to the High Court of Justice.
Conclusion
The above is a mere snapshot of the full report—which I again encourage everyone to read. A reminder that The Lancet estimated last June that Israel’s siege on Gaza has killed at least 186,000 Palestinians. The Israeli government has faced zero accountability for these clear violations of international human rights law. Nor has President Biden enforced the U.S. Leahy Laws to stop funding and arming these war crimes.
This is what intentional genocide looks like, and it is absolutely indefensible. The UN Commission details a thorough investigation, and concludes that virtually every, if not every, justification cited by Netanyahu to perpetuate his siege on Gaza is based on misinformation and disinformation. Meanwhile, legacy media remains largely silent on this ongoing US funded atrocity. The US Government must stop being complicit Netanyahu’s war crimes and genocide. And we must keep raising our voices to demand justice and accountability.
For my part, you have my commitment to continue to demand justice in all matters by placing human rights and human dignity above all else. Thank you for support in elevating this work and advocacy.
Why Your Support Matters: Every dollar we spend is a vote for the kind of future we want. Help me create a future more committed to justice and universal human rights. Subscribe, and I welcome your thoughts, feedback, and insights. Thank you.
Netanyahu‘s desire to halt his corruption trial and the fact that his government coalition only holds the exact correct number of seats in the Knesset to ensure that he stays in power and remains Prime Minister, likely drives a very large part of why the war has gone on this long and with this level of depravity.
A single defection from that morally corrupt far right government coalition would collapse his government. That’s not justification. That is atrocity in the service of a naked desire to stay in power and to avoid accountability. It would be embarrassing if it were within the capacity of any of these people to feel such.
What I will say is I do not understand President Biden’s not holding Netanyahu to (much) more account, especially given how much of a micromanagement stranglehold he has had for Ukraine, which is itself an an attacked country in an existential battle for its own survival, against an enemy who has no interest in negotiations short of complete surrender. Biden is genuinely the finest president since FDR in many ways, with the sour note of this one-two punch of moral turpitude.
I do not say this to equate Ukraine with Israel, but to recognize that I genuinely do not understand behaving one way with one country, and behaving the complete opposite way with another country. Especially when those countries are the opposite sides of being attacked versus being the aggressor fighting a war of chosen aggression.
I think it is entirely fair to couch it in these terms, even if Israel was grievously attacked on October 7. This war was not the sole option available for responding to October 7, it is and it was the worst and most unjustifiable approach to choose.
Thank you for looking squarely at the face of such immense suffering. It is awful. It is necessary.
I expected the UN to get more involved after Israel started attacking UN outposts and UN schools. Do they have no power at all? Is there anything the UN can do in this situation, or why haven't they done anything?